Blue Jays to land $119 million fruition deal for All-Star who fits ‘better’ than Pete Alonso

The Toronto Blue Jays made their most significant move in free agency by signing Anthony Santander. While they remain in the running for Pete Alonso, there may be a more suitable option available.

Alex Bregman is still a free agent, and with the Houston Astros trading Ryan Pressly, it’s possible Bregman could remain in Houston. However, ESPN’s David Schoenfield pointed out that Bregman might actually be a better fit for the Blue Jays than Alonso, highlighting reasons why teams should pursue Bregman.

“Third base is occupied by Ernie Clement, a career journeyman who had a 3.4-WAR season in 2024 at age 28 — thanks, in large part, to some excellent defensive metrics at third base and shortstop,” wrote Schoenfield. “Though Clement has elite contact ability, he pairs that with poor swing decisions and low hard-hit rates. He works best as a utility player, and Bregman fits the roster better than Pete Alonso, another free agent the Jays are pursuing — but one who would force Guerrero to move to third base … which isn’t the brightest idea.”

 

While Alonso is undoubtedly a more powerful hitter than Bregman, the latter brings Gold Glove defense at third base and consistent offensive production. Bregman has a career .272 batting average and 191 home runs.

In 2024, Bregman hit 26 home runs and drove in 75 RBIs. He’s a two-time All-Star, Gold Glove winner, and Silver Slugger. Unlike Alonso, Bregman wouldn’t require the Blue Jays to shift Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to a different position and would come at a lower cost. Spotrac forecasts Bregman to sign a four-year, $119 million contract.

Schoenfield pointed out that the Blue Jays have reportedly extended a six-year offer to Bregman.