The New York Mets may soon face the consequences of not extending Pete Alonso’s contract. As one of their most reliable offensive players, Alonso’s exit leaves a significant void in the heart of their lineup. Despite having the financial ability to keep him, the Mets opted for a different approach, focusing on younger internal players like Mark Vientos or versatile options like Jurickson Profar.
Once a Franchise Pillar
For years, Alonso was a central figure in the Mets’ lineup and a recognizable face of the team. His knack for delivering in key moments and his endurance—playing every game last season—made him essential to their offensive success.
In 2024, Alonso posted a .240/.329/.459 line with 34 home runs, 88 RBIs, and a 122 wRC+. While Juan Soto will likely become the new face of the team, Alonso’s consistency and the identity he brought to the Mets are hard to overlook.
Reports suggest the Mets offered Alonso a three-year deal without opt-outs, providing short-term flexibility and avoiding a long-term commitment. However, Alonso sought opt-outs as security, leading to a deadlock that neither side resolved. This stalemate pushed the Mets toward a contingency plan that now appears somewhat makeshift.
Vientos as the Replacement
With Alonso no longer at first base, the Mets are expected to move Mark Vientos to the position. Though Vientos has promising offensive potential, his defense is still a question mark. In 89 innings at first base, he recorded -1 outs above average and two defensive runs saved, indicating that his defensive skills need further development.
Offensively, Vientos had a solid 2024, hitting .266/.322/.516 with 27 home runs, 71 RBIs, and a 133 wRC+. The Mets see him as a key future player, but transitioning him to first base full-time carries risks, especially for a team aiming to compete in the NL East.
Profar as a Utility Option
The Mets could also utilize Jurickson Profar, known for his versatility across infield and outfield positions, including first base. While Profar lacks Alonso’s power, his ability to play multiple positions offers flexibility for a team undergoing substantial roster changes. Profar is coming off a strong offensive season with a 139 wRC+, outperforming Alonso in that regard.
A Bold but Risky Strategy
The Mets’ offseason approach is bold, with potential for high rewards. While some of their moves paid off in 2024, letting Alonso go and relying on internal options like Vientos and versatile players like Profar is a gamble. Alonso’s combination of power, durability, and leadership is hard to replace, and the Mets are betting their restructured roster can compensate for his absence.
Time will reveal whether the Mets’ strategy succeeds, but Alonso’s departure leaves a noticeable gap in their lineup—and perhaps their clubhouse. If Alonso thrives elsewhere, the Mets might find themselves questioning the choice they made.
Leave a Reply