Sal Stewart’s MLB debut has turned out to be both what fans might have anticipated and not at all what he could have expected. The rookie, who cruised through the minor leagues, has provided a much-needed lift to the Cincinnati Reds, but he’s also found himself in an unfamiliar role—literally.
With just two Minor League games at first base under his belt, Stewart is now tasked with playing the position in some of the highest-pressure situations early on in his career. Fortunately for him, the Reds have a legend who is eager to guide the next generation.
Just two seasons ago, Joey Votto was in a similar situation, mentoring his potential replacement. During spring training and a rehab stint at Triple-A Louisville, the former MVP helped Christian Encarnacion-Strand transition from third base to first. While the results didn’t fully match expectations—likely due to the weight of filling Votto’s shoes—the mentorship was successful. If Votto is willing, he could be the key to helping Stewart succeed where Encarnacion-Strand faced difficulties.
Joey Votto’s expertise at first base will unlock Sal Stewart’s potential
What Stewart really needs from Votto isn’t necessarily his fielding skills; since Statcast started tracking fielding in 2016, Votto has posted a -25 outs above average at first base. Instead, what Votto can offer is the poise and confidence a young star needs to thrive.
Stewart has already earned praise for his maturity and work ethic, but learning how to embrace the grind from Votto—who knows how to find joy in the struggle—could help Stewart settle into his new role and adjust to life with his new teammates.
Votto, after all, has a lot of experience stepping into a tense clubhouse in September. When he made his MLB debut in 2007, the Reds had already fired their manager and were 14 games under .500. Pressure comes in many forms, and the weight of a team struggling to finish a dreadful season can be just as intense as a team chasing a playoff spot. Votto rose to the occasion, hitting four home runs and seven doubles in 24 games. The team still finished 10-14, but Votto’s performance gave fans hope for brighter days ahead.
Stewart could play a similar role for the 2025 Reds. Regardless of whether the team makes the playoffs, the end of the season will give Cincinnati something to build on. Votto finished as the runner-up for Rookie of the Year in 2008, and just two years later, the team was in the playoffs. With Votto’s guidance, Stewart might be able to spark a similar turnaround.
Leave a Reply